272 Old Montauk Hwy Hilltop 5 || $5,250,000 || For Sale

For Sale


272 Old Montauk Hwy Hilltop Unit #5, Montauk, NY 11954

Situated on Montauk's most pristine stretch of oceanfront real estate, Hilltop 5 is the first and only resale opportunity on the Hilltop Level. Situated steps to the ocean, this two bedroom plus additional sleeping loft provides dramatic views of the ocean while offering a turn-key living experience at Gurney's Residences. This unit has been completely reimagined and renovated with 5-inch white oak floors, smart home capabilities, and elegant design details throughout. Upon entry, vaulted ceilings and walls of glass allow for an abundance of natural light and endless, serene water views from every room. The completely updated open-concept kitchen features solid white-oak brushed cabinetry, Italian Luce di Luna quartz waterfall countertops, Subzero and Wolf appliances including a six-burner range and wine fridge, and ample storage. Double-wide sliding doors open to your private terrace that features a custom Wolf outdoor kitchen, dining and lounging for plenty. The main living space features a custom gas fireplace draped in matching Italian quartz, plus a discreet ladder that takes you to the built-in sleeping loft with storage and two twin beds- unique to this residence only. Exquisite design details include walls of shiplap that bring you to the lower level where you'll find the expansive master suite and an additional ensuite guest bedroom. The master suite includes a soaking tub, custom walk-in closet, and a private terrace with built-in hot tub that invites the ocean breeze in. This home comes with private parking and a dedicated owners' beach cabana and a five-year membership to all of the Gurney's resort amenities. Gurney's Residences are designed to offer its residents a lifestyle like no other - the ability to experience all of the benefits of residential ownership, without any of the worry. Our team offers an entire suite of services that allow you to own and manage your investment, effortlessly, including 24-hour concierge, onsite security monitoring, valet parking, pre-arrival services, housekeeping, building management/maintenance. Additional amenities include butler service with preparation for arrival, landscaping and security, water-sport equipment storage, and private chefs and event coordinators for clambakes and private bonfires. Owners will also have access to five unique dining and social venues, room service and daily maid service, kids club, beach nannies, and the Beach Club. To be complete Fall 2022 is a completely renovated Seawater Spa - a luxury spa designed by the same group as Aire Ancient Baths, with a world-famous indoor, ocean-fed seawater pool with panoramic views of the Atlantic, the only pool of its kind in North America. The spa also includes a Roman plunge bath, sauna, whirlpool, and a 24-hour fitness center with complimentary yoga, spin, boot camp, private trainers, and Pilates classes. This residence is available for immediate move-in

Area & Lot

For Sale
Living Space
2,300 Sq.Ft.
View Description
Water View


Total Bathrooms
Full Bathrooms
Half Bathroom


Air Conditioning


Sales Price

Property Images


Work With Us

White-glove client service, ingenious marketing strategies, scrupulous business practices and record - breaking sales deals make the Alexander Team one of the top - producing and most recognized real estate names in New York and the U.S. today
Follow Us